State Violence, Empire and the Figure of the "Soldier-Victim" in Northern Ireland

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article examines some of the deeper meanings of the denial of accountability in killings perpetrated by British soldiers during the conflict in Northern Ireland, as part of the debate on how to deal with the legacy of the past. It investigates the ways in which such ‘soldier-perpetrators’ are turned, instead, into ‘soldier-victims’ and asks what this tells us about the political culture that shapes such a response. In part, it will be argued, this is the product of a longer term Manichean distinction, deeply embedded in the history of empire and its wars, between ‘civilians’ and barbarians’. Here lawfulness, as a mark of ‘civility’, is identified with the self-image of the (post-) imperial state, contrasted with the unlawful chaos of the barbarian ‘Other’. In the context of both the counterinsurgency wars of the late twentieth and early twenty-first century, and amid a presiding mood of ‘post-imperial melancholia’ and ‘heroic failure’, the figure of the ‘soldier-victim’ therefore becomes a means to turn the wrongs of state violence into an ideological potent imaginary of empire, the state (and its agents) as themselves those who have been wronged.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-20
Number of pages20
JournalJournal of Labor and Society
Early online date23 Apr 2019
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 23 Apr 2019

Fingerprint

Northern Ireland
Soldiers
Barbarians
Accountability
Counterinsurgency
History
British Soldiers
Denial
Civility
Mood
Melancholia
Political Culture
Killing
Chaos
Perpetrators

Keywords

  • State Violence
  • Northern Ireland
  • Afghanistan
  • Soldier Victim

Cite this

@article{7338936bb7744430b10f632f3164baa1,
title = "State Violence, Empire and the Figure of the {"}Soldier-Victim{"} in Northern Ireland",
abstract = "This article examines some of the deeper meanings of the denial of accountability in killings perpetrated by British soldiers during the conflict in Northern Ireland, as part of the debate on how to deal with the legacy of the past. It investigates the ways in which such ‘soldier-perpetrators’ are turned, instead, into ‘soldier-victims’ and asks what this tells us about the political culture that shapes such a response. In part, it will be argued, this is the product of a longer term Manichean distinction, deeply embedded in the history of empire and its wars, between ‘civilians’ and barbarians’. Here lawfulness, as a mark of ‘civility’, is identified with the self-image of the (post-) imperial state, contrasted with the unlawful chaos of the barbarian ‘Other’. In the context of both the counterinsurgency wars of the late twentieth and early twenty-first century, and amid a presiding mood of ‘post-imperial melancholia’ and ‘heroic failure’, the figure of the ‘soldier-victim’ therefore becomes a means to turn the wrongs of state violence into an ideological potent imaginary of empire, the state (and its agents) as themselves those who have been wronged.",
keywords = "State Violence, Northern Ireland, Afghanistan, Soldier Victim",
author = "MARK MCGOVERN",
year = "2019",
month = "4",
day = "23",
language = "English",
pages = "1--20",
journal = "Journal of Labor and Society",
issn = "2471-4607",

}

State Violence, Empire and the Figure of the "Soldier-Victim" in Northern Ireland. / MCGOVERN, MARK.

In: Journal of Labor and Society, 23.04.2019, p. 1-20.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - State Violence, Empire and the Figure of the "Soldier-Victim" in Northern Ireland

AU - MCGOVERN, MARK

PY - 2019/4/23

Y1 - 2019/4/23

N2 - This article examines some of the deeper meanings of the denial of accountability in killings perpetrated by British soldiers during the conflict in Northern Ireland, as part of the debate on how to deal with the legacy of the past. It investigates the ways in which such ‘soldier-perpetrators’ are turned, instead, into ‘soldier-victims’ and asks what this tells us about the political culture that shapes such a response. In part, it will be argued, this is the product of a longer term Manichean distinction, deeply embedded in the history of empire and its wars, between ‘civilians’ and barbarians’. Here lawfulness, as a mark of ‘civility’, is identified with the self-image of the (post-) imperial state, contrasted with the unlawful chaos of the barbarian ‘Other’. In the context of both the counterinsurgency wars of the late twentieth and early twenty-first century, and amid a presiding mood of ‘post-imperial melancholia’ and ‘heroic failure’, the figure of the ‘soldier-victim’ therefore becomes a means to turn the wrongs of state violence into an ideological potent imaginary of empire, the state (and its agents) as themselves those who have been wronged.

AB - This article examines some of the deeper meanings of the denial of accountability in killings perpetrated by British soldiers during the conflict in Northern Ireland, as part of the debate on how to deal with the legacy of the past. It investigates the ways in which such ‘soldier-perpetrators’ are turned, instead, into ‘soldier-victims’ and asks what this tells us about the political culture that shapes such a response. In part, it will be argued, this is the product of a longer term Manichean distinction, deeply embedded in the history of empire and its wars, between ‘civilians’ and barbarians’. Here lawfulness, as a mark of ‘civility’, is identified with the self-image of the (post-) imperial state, contrasted with the unlawful chaos of the barbarian ‘Other’. In the context of both the counterinsurgency wars of the late twentieth and early twenty-first century, and amid a presiding mood of ‘post-imperial melancholia’ and ‘heroic failure’, the figure of the ‘soldier-victim’ therefore becomes a means to turn the wrongs of state violence into an ideological potent imaginary of empire, the state (and its agents) as themselves those who have been wronged.

KW - State Violence

KW - Northern Ireland

KW - Afghanistan

KW - Soldier Victim

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 20

JO - Journal of Labor and Society

JF - Journal of Labor and Society

SN - 2471-4607

ER -