Real world, real people: Can we assess walking on a treadmill to establish step count recommendations in adolescents?

Mhairi MacDonald, Samantha Fawkner, Ailsa Niven, David Rowe

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

19 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Background: It is currently not known how much walking should be advocated for good health in an adolescent population. Step count recommendations for minimum time in moderate intensity activity have been translated predominantly from treadmill walking. The aim of this study was to compare the energy cost of walking on a treadmill with overground walking in adolescent girls. Method: Twenty six adolescent girls undertook resting metabolic measurements for individual determination of one MET using indirect calorimetry. Energy expenditure was subsequently assessed during treadmill and overground walking at slow, moderate and fast walking speeds for 4 – 6 minutes. Treadmill step rates were matched overground using a metronome. Result: The energy cost of treadmill walking was found to be significantly greater than and not equivalent to overground walking at 133step∙min-¹ (equivalent to the fast walking pace) V̇O2 3.90 [2.78 to 5.01] P<0.001, MAPE =18.18%, METs 0.77[0.54 to 34 1.00] P<0.001, MAPE =18.16%. The oxygen cost per step ( V̇O2 ml· step -¹) was significantly greater and not equivalent on the treadmill at 120 and 133step∙min-¹, 0.43 [0.12 to 0.56] P<0.05,  MAPE =10.12%, 1.40[1.01 to 1.76] P<0.001, MAPE =17.64% respectively. Conclusion: The results suggest that there is a difference in energy cost per step of walking on a treadmill and overground at the same step rate. This should be considered when utilising the treadmill in energy expenditure studies. Studies which aim to provide step recommendations should focus on overground walking where most walking activity is adopted.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-7
Number of pages7
JournalPediatric Exercise Science
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 20 May 2019

Fingerprint

Walking
Costs and Cost Analysis
Energy Metabolism
Indirect Calorimetry
Oxygen
Population

Keywords

  • Ambulatory activity
  • Cadence
  • Assessment mode
  • Youth
  • Guidelines

Cite this

@article{55bbb780676d4cfaa3fc8f7433e7386e,
title = "Real world, real people: Can we assess walking on a treadmill to establish step count recommendations in adolescents?",
abstract = "Background: It is currently not known how much walking should be advocated for good health in an adolescent population. Step count recommendations for minimum time in moderate intensity activity have been translated predominantly from treadmill walking. The aim of this study was to compare the energy cost of walking on a treadmill with overground walking in adolescent girls. Method: Twenty six adolescent girls undertook resting metabolic measurements for individual determination of one MET using indirect calorimetry. Energy expenditure was subsequently assessed during treadmill and overground walking at slow, moderate and fast walking speeds for 4 – 6 minutes. Treadmill step rates were matched overground using a metronome. Result: The energy cost of treadmill walking was found to be significantly greater than and not equivalent to overground walking at 133step∙min-¹ (equivalent to the fast walking pace) V̇O2 3.90 [2.78 to 5.01] P<0.001, MAPE =18.18{\%}, METs 0.77[0.54 to 34 1.00] P<0.001, MAPE =18.16{\%}. The oxygen cost per step ( V̇O2 ml· step -¹) was significantly greater and not equivalent on the treadmill at 120 and 133step∙min-¹, 0.43 [0.12 to 0.56] P<0.05,  MAPE =10.12{\%}, 1.40[1.01 to 1.76] P<0.001, MAPE =17.64{\%} respectively. Conclusion: The results suggest that there is a difference in energy cost per step of walking on a treadmill and overground at the same step rate. This should be considered when utilising the treadmill in energy expenditure studies. Studies which aim to provide step recommendations should focus on overground walking where most walking activity is adopted.",
keywords = "Ambulatory activity, Cadence, Assessment mode, Youth, Guidelines",
author = "Mhairi MacDonald and Samantha Fawkner and Ailsa Niven and David Rowe",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "20",
doi = "https://journals.humankinetics.com/doi/10.1123/pes.2018-0213",
language = "English",
pages = "1--7",
journal = "Pediatric Exercise Science",
issn = "0899-8493",
publisher = "Human Kinetics",

}

Real world, real people: Can we assess walking on a treadmill to establish step count recommendations in adolescents? / MacDonald, Mhairi; Fawkner, Samantha; Niven, Ailsa; Rowe, David.

In: Pediatric Exercise Science, 20.05.2019, p. 1-7.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Real world, real people: Can we assess walking on a treadmill to establish step count recommendations in adolescents?

AU - MacDonald, Mhairi

AU - Fawkner, Samantha

AU - Niven, Ailsa

AU - Rowe, David

PY - 2019/5/20

Y1 - 2019/5/20

N2 - Background: It is currently not known how much walking should be advocated for good health in an adolescent population. Step count recommendations for minimum time in moderate intensity activity have been translated predominantly from treadmill walking. The aim of this study was to compare the energy cost of walking on a treadmill with overground walking in adolescent girls. Method: Twenty six adolescent girls undertook resting metabolic measurements for individual determination of one MET using indirect calorimetry. Energy expenditure was subsequently assessed during treadmill and overground walking at slow, moderate and fast walking speeds for 4 – 6 minutes. Treadmill step rates were matched overground using a metronome. Result: The energy cost of treadmill walking was found to be significantly greater than and not equivalent to overground walking at 133step∙min-¹ (equivalent to the fast walking pace) V̇O2 3.90 [2.78 to 5.01] P<0.001, MAPE =18.18%, METs 0.77[0.54 to 34 1.00] P<0.001, MAPE =18.16%. The oxygen cost per step ( V̇O2 ml· step -¹) was significantly greater and not equivalent on the treadmill at 120 and 133step∙min-¹, 0.43 [0.12 to 0.56] P<0.05,  MAPE =10.12%, 1.40[1.01 to 1.76] P<0.001, MAPE =17.64% respectively. Conclusion: The results suggest that there is a difference in energy cost per step of walking on a treadmill and overground at the same step rate. This should be considered when utilising the treadmill in energy expenditure studies. Studies which aim to provide step recommendations should focus on overground walking where most walking activity is adopted.

AB - Background: It is currently not known how much walking should be advocated for good health in an adolescent population. Step count recommendations for minimum time in moderate intensity activity have been translated predominantly from treadmill walking. The aim of this study was to compare the energy cost of walking on a treadmill with overground walking in adolescent girls. Method: Twenty six adolescent girls undertook resting metabolic measurements for individual determination of one MET using indirect calorimetry. Energy expenditure was subsequently assessed during treadmill and overground walking at slow, moderate and fast walking speeds for 4 – 6 minutes. Treadmill step rates were matched overground using a metronome. Result: The energy cost of treadmill walking was found to be significantly greater than and not equivalent to overground walking at 133step∙min-¹ (equivalent to the fast walking pace) V̇O2 3.90 [2.78 to 5.01] P<0.001, MAPE =18.18%, METs 0.77[0.54 to 34 1.00] P<0.001, MAPE =18.16%. The oxygen cost per step ( V̇O2 ml· step -¹) was significantly greater and not equivalent on the treadmill at 120 and 133step∙min-¹, 0.43 [0.12 to 0.56] P<0.05,  MAPE =10.12%, 1.40[1.01 to 1.76] P<0.001, MAPE =17.64% respectively. Conclusion: The results suggest that there is a difference in energy cost per step of walking on a treadmill and overground at the same step rate. This should be considered when utilising the treadmill in energy expenditure studies. Studies which aim to provide step recommendations should focus on overground walking where most walking activity is adopted.

KW - Ambulatory activity

KW - Cadence

KW - Assessment mode

KW - Youth

KW - Guidelines

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/real-world-real-people-we-assess-walking-treadmill-establish-step-count-recommendations-adolescents

U2 - https://journals.humankinetics.com/doi/10.1123/pes.2018-0213

DO - https://journals.humankinetics.com/doi/10.1123/pes.2018-0213

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 7

JO - Pediatric Exercise Science

JF - Pediatric Exercise Science

SN - 0899-8493

ER -