Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Much of what is written about northern soul treats it as a historical subject and phenomenon of the past. This chapter explores how fans have retained a longterm commitment to northern soul by continuing active involvement in the various scenes that exist in the UK. It also considers some of the ways the past and present interrelate and manifest in fans’ lives. Exploring commitment illustrates the meaning and socio-cultural experiences of sustained fandom. This chapter argues that nostalgia, memory and familiarity clearly play a role in northern soul as the acquisition of symbolic knowledge demonstrates an understanding of etiquette, cultural activities, and ultimately cements a fan’s position as a genuine ‘soulie’. This is not to suggest that older fans are ‘clinging onto’ their youth, rather, they look back on their past involvement often with fondness and, in turn, this informs their present involvement. Symbolic knowledge also highlights the male-dominated nature of northern soul. Cultural distinctions alongside concerns with credibility and rarity lead to a sense of solidarity and belonging for fans, which is amplified and extended through long-term involvement. This chapter concludes by exploring generational tension amongst original members of the scene and younger newcomers as issues of ownership and status result in contention between traditionalists and those that feel the scene should progress.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Northern Soul Scene
EditorsNicola Smith, Sarah, Elizabeth Raine, Tim Wall
PublisherEquinox
ISBN (Print)9781781795583
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2019

Publication series

NameStudies in Popular Music

Fingerprint

nostalgia
fan
credibility
commitment
present
experience

Keywords

  • Northern Soul
  • nostalgia
  • generational conflict

Cite this

Gibson, L. (2019). Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict. In N. Smith, S. E. Raine, & T. Wall (Eds.), The Northern Soul Scene (Studies in Popular Music). Equinox.
Gibson, Lucy. / Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict. The Northern Soul Scene. editor / Nicola Smith ; Sarah, Elizabeth Raine ; Tim Wall. Equinox, 2019. (Studies in Popular Music).
@inbook{a25cc6f0a90f404e815946d27ba8fc0b,
title = "Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict",
abstract = "Much of what is written about northern soul treats it as a historical subject and phenomenon of the past. This chapter explores how fans have retained a longterm commitment to northern soul by continuing active involvement in the various scenes that exist in the UK. It also considers some of the ways the past and present interrelate and manifest in fans’ lives. Exploring commitment illustrates the meaning and socio-cultural experiences of sustained fandom. This chapter argues that nostalgia, memory and familiarity clearly play a role in northern soul as the acquisition of symbolic knowledge demonstrates an understanding of etiquette, cultural activities, and ultimately cements a fan’s position as a genuine ‘soulie’. This is not to suggest that older fans are ‘clinging onto’ their youth, rather, they look back on their past involvement often with fondness and, in turn, this informs their present involvement. Symbolic knowledge also highlights the male-dominated nature of northern soul. Cultural distinctions alongside concerns with credibility and rarity lead to a sense of solidarity and belonging for fans, which is amplified and extended through long-term involvement. This chapter concludes by exploring generational tension amongst original members of the scene and younger newcomers as issues of ownership and status result in contention between traditionalists and those that feel the scene should progress.",
keywords = "Northern Soul, nostalgia, generational conflict",
author = "Lucy Gibson",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "1",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781781795583",
series = "Studies in Popular Music",
publisher = "Equinox",
editor = "Nicola Smith and Raine, {Sarah, Elizabeth} and Tim Wall",
booktitle = "The Northern Soul Scene",

}

Gibson, L 2019, Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict. in N Smith, SE Raine & T Wall (eds), The Northern Soul Scene. Studies in Popular Music, Equinox.

Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict. / Gibson, Lucy.

The Northern Soul Scene. ed. / Nicola Smith; Sarah, Elizabeth Raine; Tim Wall. Equinox, 2019. (Studies in Popular Music).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict

AU - Gibson, Lucy

PY - 2019/9/1

Y1 - 2019/9/1

N2 - Much of what is written about northern soul treats it as a historical subject and phenomenon of the past. This chapter explores how fans have retained a longterm commitment to northern soul by continuing active involvement in the various scenes that exist in the UK. It also considers some of the ways the past and present interrelate and manifest in fans’ lives. Exploring commitment illustrates the meaning and socio-cultural experiences of sustained fandom. This chapter argues that nostalgia, memory and familiarity clearly play a role in northern soul as the acquisition of symbolic knowledge demonstrates an understanding of etiquette, cultural activities, and ultimately cements a fan’s position as a genuine ‘soulie’. This is not to suggest that older fans are ‘clinging onto’ their youth, rather, they look back on their past involvement often with fondness and, in turn, this informs their present involvement. Symbolic knowledge also highlights the male-dominated nature of northern soul. Cultural distinctions alongside concerns with credibility and rarity lead to a sense of solidarity and belonging for fans, which is amplified and extended through long-term involvement. This chapter concludes by exploring generational tension amongst original members of the scene and younger newcomers as issues of ownership and status result in contention between traditionalists and those that feel the scene should progress.

AB - Much of what is written about northern soul treats it as a historical subject and phenomenon of the past. This chapter explores how fans have retained a longterm commitment to northern soul by continuing active involvement in the various scenes that exist in the UK. It also considers some of the ways the past and present interrelate and manifest in fans’ lives. Exploring commitment illustrates the meaning and socio-cultural experiences of sustained fandom. This chapter argues that nostalgia, memory and familiarity clearly play a role in northern soul as the acquisition of symbolic knowledge demonstrates an understanding of etiquette, cultural activities, and ultimately cements a fan’s position as a genuine ‘soulie’. This is not to suggest that older fans are ‘clinging onto’ their youth, rather, they look back on their past involvement often with fondness and, in turn, this informs their present involvement. Symbolic knowledge also highlights the male-dominated nature of northern soul. Cultural distinctions alongside concerns with credibility and rarity lead to a sense of solidarity and belonging for fans, which is amplified and extended through long-term involvement. This chapter concludes by exploring generational tension amongst original members of the scene and younger newcomers as issues of ownership and status result in contention between traditionalists and those that feel the scene should progress.

KW - Northern Soul

KW - nostalgia

KW - generational conflict

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781781795583

T3 - Studies in Popular Music

BT - The Northern Soul Scene

A2 - Smith, Nicola

A2 - Raine, Sarah, Elizabeth

A2 - Wall, Tim

PB - Equinox

ER -

Gibson L. Nostalgia, symbolic knowledge and generational conflict. In Smith N, Raine SE, Wall T, editors, The Northern Soul Scene. Equinox. 2019. (Studies in Popular Music).