Holding children for procedures; an international survey of health professionals

Lucy Bray, Bernie Carter, Karen Ford, Annette Dickinson, Tineke Water, Lucy Blake

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)
18 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Children undergoing clinical procedures can experience pain and/or anxiety. This may result in them being unwilling to co-operate and being held still by parents or health professionals. This study aimed to capture an international perspective of health professionals’ reported practices of holding children still for clinical procedures. An online questionnaire was distributed through network sampling to health professionals working with children aged under 16 years of age. 872 responses were obtained from Australia (n=477), NZ (n=237) and the UK (n=158). Responses were from nurses (n=651), doctors (n=159) and other professionals (n=53). Health professionals reported children as held still for clinical procedures quite often (48%) or very often (33%). Levels of holding varied significantly according to country of practice, profession, student status, length of time working within a clinical setting, training received and the availability of resources in the workplace. Health professionals who gained permissions (assent from children and/or consent from parents) before procedures were less likely to hold children still for a clinical procedure than those who did not. Holding children still for procedures is an international practice which is influenced by training, access to guidance, country of practice and profession. Children’s permission and parental consent is often not sought before a child is held for a procedure to be completed.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)205-215
JournalJournal of Child Health Care
Volume22
Issue number2
Early online date21 Jan 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2018

Fingerprint

Health Surveys
Health
Parents
Parental Consent
Internationality
Professional Practice
Workplace
Anxiety
Nurses
Students
Pain

Keywords

  • Assent
  • children
  • clinical procedures
  • clinical holding
  • consent

Cite this

@article{db57a0b2a5fa4faa9c31de5837e4ef1c,
title = "Holding children for procedures; an international survey of health professionals",
abstract = "Children undergoing clinical procedures can experience pain and/or anxiety. This may result in them being unwilling to co-operate and being held still by parents or health professionals. This study aimed to capture an international perspective of health professionals’ reported practices of holding children still for clinical procedures. An online questionnaire was distributed through network sampling to health professionals working with children aged under 16 years of age. 872 responses were obtained from Australia (n=477), NZ (n=237) and the UK (n=158). Responses were from nurses (n=651), doctors (n=159) and other professionals (n=53). Health professionals reported children as held still for clinical procedures quite often (48{\%}) or very often (33{\%}). Levels of holding varied significantly according to country of practice, profession, student status, length of time working within a clinical setting, training received and the availability of resources in the workplace. Health professionals who gained permissions (assent from children and/or consent from parents) before procedures were less likely to hold children still for a clinical procedure than those who did not. Holding children still for procedures is an international practice which is influenced by training, access to guidance, country of practice and profession. Children’s permission and parental consent is often not sought before a child is held for a procedure to be completed.",
keywords = "Assent, children, clinical procedures, clinical holding, consent",
author = "Lucy Bray and Bernie Carter and Karen Ford and Annette Dickinson and Tineke Water and Lucy Blake",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "https://doi.org/10.1177/1367493517752499",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "205--215",
journal = "Journal of Child Health Care",
issn = "1367-4935",
publisher = "Taylor and Francis",
number = "2",

}

Holding children for procedures; an international survey of health professionals. / Bray, Lucy; Carter, Bernie; Ford, Karen; Dickinson, Annette; Water, Tineke; Blake, Lucy.

In: Journal of Child Health Care, Vol. 22, No. 2, 01.06.2018, p. 205-215.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Holding children for procedures; an international survey of health professionals

AU - Bray, Lucy

AU - Carter, Bernie

AU - Ford, Karen

AU - Dickinson, Annette

AU - Water, Tineke

AU - Blake, Lucy

PY - 2018/6/1

Y1 - 2018/6/1

N2 - Children undergoing clinical procedures can experience pain and/or anxiety. This may result in them being unwilling to co-operate and being held still by parents or health professionals. This study aimed to capture an international perspective of health professionals’ reported practices of holding children still for clinical procedures. An online questionnaire was distributed through network sampling to health professionals working with children aged under 16 years of age. 872 responses were obtained from Australia (n=477), NZ (n=237) and the UK (n=158). Responses were from nurses (n=651), doctors (n=159) and other professionals (n=53). Health professionals reported children as held still for clinical procedures quite often (48%) or very often (33%). Levels of holding varied significantly according to country of practice, profession, student status, length of time working within a clinical setting, training received and the availability of resources in the workplace. Health professionals who gained permissions (assent from children and/or consent from parents) before procedures were less likely to hold children still for a clinical procedure than those who did not. Holding children still for procedures is an international practice which is influenced by training, access to guidance, country of practice and profession. Children’s permission and parental consent is often not sought before a child is held for a procedure to be completed.

AB - Children undergoing clinical procedures can experience pain and/or anxiety. This may result in them being unwilling to co-operate and being held still by parents or health professionals. This study aimed to capture an international perspective of health professionals’ reported practices of holding children still for clinical procedures. An online questionnaire was distributed through network sampling to health professionals working with children aged under 16 years of age. 872 responses were obtained from Australia (n=477), NZ (n=237) and the UK (n=158). Responses were from nurses (n=651), doctors (n=159) and other professionals (n=53). Health professionals reported children as held still for clinical procedures quite often (48%) or very often (33%). Levels of holding varied significantly according to country of practice, profession, student status, length of time working within a clinical setting, training received and the availability of resources in the workplace. Health professionals who gained permissions (assent from children and/or consent from parents) before procedures were less likely to hold children still for a clinical procedure than those who did not. Holding children still for procedures is an international practice which is influenced by training, access to guidance, country of practice and profession. Children’s permission and parental consent is often not sought before a child is held for a procedure to be completed.

KW - Assent

KW - children

KW - clinical procedures

KW - clinical holding

KW - consent

U2 - https://doi.org/10.1177/1367493517752499

DO - https://doi.org/10.1177/1367493517752499

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 205

EP - 215

JO - Journal of Child Health Care

JF - Journal of Child Health Care

SN - 1367-4935

IS - 2

ER -