@article{54af6ac5be3b40bc8339b81c0f7870ba,
title = "Dealing with disaffection: The influence of work-based learning on 14–16-year-old students{\textquoteright} attitudes to school",
abstract = "Abstract Background: Recent developments in policy concerned with raising achievement in schools have given rise to work-based learning as a mechanism for dealing with disaffection. Alongside this redress is the potential for promoting alternative pathways into further education and/or employment. This paper looks at the impact of a work-based learning programme on engagement/re-engagement for disaffected 14–16-year-olds. Drawing on data collected in a small borough in the north of England, it examines attitudes to learning in school and a vocational learning environment. Methods: Teachers{\textquoteright} and tutors{\textquoteright} attitudinal scoring of disaffected students was collected in school and a work-based learning provider, and interviews were conducted with a smaller sample of the students. Results: The retention of a strong school connection is identified as crucial in improving attitude to learning in disaffected students, while attitude and engagement is shown to be heavily interrelated. Students who solely attend a work-based learning provider are seen to further dissociate from school. Conclusions: This study explores the relationship between engagement and attitude to learning in disaffected 14-16-year-olds. Vocational learning is seen to be highly engaging and promotes an overall improvement in general attitude to learning. In relation to school, however, there is strong evidence of reinforced negative attitudes and further disaffection when students are fully removed from this environment. Thus, the most potent recipe for dealing with disaffection in this research is shown to be a mixture of environments where a connection with school is retained.",
keywords = "Disaffection, Vocational learning, Student attitudes",
author = "David Allan",
note = "Ahlgren L, Tett L (2010) Work-based learning, identity and organisational culture. Studies in Continuing Education 32(1):17–27 Allan D (2014) Quantity for quality: a case study on the impact of an English work-based learning programme on disaffected pupils{\textquoteright} qualification achievements. Educate~ 14(1):10–16 Avis J, Fisher R, Ollin R (2010) Professionalism. In: Avis R, Fisher R, Thompson R (eds) Teaching in lifelong learning: a guide to theory and practice. Open University Press, Maidenhead Bentley T (1999) Learning beyond the classroom. Routledge, London Billett S (2003) Vocational curriculum and pedagogy: an activity theory perspective. European Educ Res J 2(1):6–21 Billett S (2006) Work, subjectivity and learning. In: Billett S, Fenwick T, Somerville M (eds) Work, subjectivity and learning: understanding learning through working life. Springer, Dordrecht Bourdieu P, Passeron JC (2000) Reproduction in education, society and culture. Sage, London Burr V (1995) An introduction to social constructionism. Routledge, London Cuddy N, Leney T (2005) Vocational education and training in the United Kingdom. Cedefop. Panorama Series, 111. Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg Davies J, Biesta G (2007) Coming to college or getting out of school? The experience of vocational learning of 14‐to 16‐year‐olds in a further education college. Research Papers in Education 22(1):23-41 Dearing R (1996) Review of qualifications for 16–19 year olds. SCAA, London DfE (2013) Full-time enrolment of 14-16 year olds in further education and sixth form colleges. DfE, London DfE (2014) 2016 Key stage 4 performance tables: inclusion of 14 to 16 qualifications. DfE, London DfES (2006) Work-related learning and the law. DfES, Nottingham Felstead A, Fuller A, Unwin L, Ashton D, Butler P, Lee T (2005) Surveying the scene: learning metaphors, survey design and the workplace context. J of Educ and Work 18(4):359–383 Feng Y, Jament J (2009) Integrated but not included: exploring quiet disaffection in mainstream schools in China and India. Int J on School Disaffection 6(1):12–18 Fuller C, Macfadyen T (2012) {\textquoteleft}What With Your Grades?{\textquoteright} Students{\textquoteright} motivation for and experiences of vocational courses in further education. J of Voc Educ & Training 64(1):87–101 Fuller A, Unwin L, Felstead A, Jewson N, Kakavelakis K (2007) Creating and using knowledge: an analysis of the differentiated nature of workplace learning environments. Brit Educ Res J 33(5):743–759 Gov.UK (2014) Increasing opportunities for young people and helping them to achieve their potential. Available via https://www.gov.uk/government/policies/increasing-opportunities-for-young-people-and-helping-them-to-achieve-their-potential/supporting-pages/raising-the-participation-age. Accessed 17 Jan 14 Hall D, Raffo C (2004) Re-engaging 14–16-year-olds with their schooling through work-related learning. J of Voc Educ and Train 56(1):69–80 Harris R, Willis P, Simons M, Collins E (2001) The relative contributions of institutional and workplace learning environments: an analysis of apprenticeship training. J of Voc Educ and Train 53(2):263–278 Hodgson A, Spours K (2008) Education and training 14–19: curriculum, Qualifications and Organization. Sage, London Hodgson A, Spours K (2010) Vocational qualifications and progression to higher education: the case of the 14–19 diplomas in the English system. J of Educ and Work 23(2):95–110 Humphrey N, Charlton JP, Newton I (2004) The developmental roots of disaffection? Educ Psych 24(5):579–594 Hyland C, Winch T (2007) Guide to vocational education and training. Continuum, London James D, Simmons J (2007) Alternative assessment for learner engagement in a climate of performativity – lessons from an English case study. Assess in Educ 14(3):353–371 Jamieson I (1993) TVEI and the work-related curriculum. Eval and Res in Educ 7(2):51–65 Jones T (2013) Through the lens of home-educated children: engagement in education. Educ Psych in Practice 29(2):107–121 Kelly S, Price P (2009) Vocational education: a clean slate for disengaged students? Social Sci Res 38(4):810–825 Klotz VK, Billett S, Winther E (2014) Promoting workforce excellence: formation and relevance of vocational identity for vocational educational training. Emp Res in Voc Educ and Training 6:6 Konkola R, Tuomi-Gr{\"o}hn T, Lambert P, Ludvigsen S (2007) Promoting learning and transfer between school and workplace. J of Educ and Work 20(3):211–228 Kyndt E, Baert H (2013) Antecedents of employees' involvement in work-related learning: a systematic review. Review of Educ Res 83(2):273–313 Lovelace M, Brickman P (2013) Research methods: best practices for measuring students{\textquoteright} attitudes toward learning science. Life Sci Educ 12(4):606–617. McKendrick J, Scott G, Sinclair S (2007) Dismissing disaffection: young people{\textquoteright}s attitudes towards education, employment and participation in a deprived community. J of Youth Studies 10(2):139–160 Radnor H (2002) Researching your professional practice: doing interpretive research. Open University Press, Milton Keynes Raelin JA (2010) Work-based learning: valuing practice as an educational event. New Directions for teaching and Learning 124:39–46. Raffo C (2003) Disaffected young people and the work-related curriculum at key stage 4: issues of social capital development and learning as a form of cultural practice. J of Educ and Work 16(1):69¬–86 Reay D (2001) Finding or losing yourself?: working-class relationships to education. J of Educ Pol 16(4):333–34 Ritchie J, Ormston R (2014) The applications of qualitative methods to social research. In: Ritchie J, Lewis J, Nichols CM, Ormston R (eds) Qualitative Research Practice. Sage, London Ross A (2009) Disengagement from education among 14-16 year olds. Research Report, DCSF RR178. Available via https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/221992/DCSF-RR178.pdf. Accessed 12 Jan 14 Sandal A, Smith K, Wangensteen R (2014) Vocational students experiences with assessment in workplace learning. Voc & Learning 7(2):241–261 Saunders M (2006) From {\textquoteleft}organisms{\textquoteright} to {\textquoteleft}boundaries{\textquoteright}: the uneven development of theory narratives in education, learning and work connections. J of Educ and Work 19(1):1¬–27 Schaffer HR (2006) Social development. Blackwell, Oxford Schmitt N, Oswald FL, Friede A, Imus A, Merritt S (2008) Perceived fit with an academic environment: attitudinal and behavioral outcomes. J of Voc Behavior 72(3):317–335 Simmons R (2009) Entry to employment: discourses of inclusion and employability in work-based learning for young people. J of Educ and Work 22(2):137¬–151 Slater SJ, Slater TF, Bailey JM (2011) Discipline-based science education research: a scientist{\textquoteright}s guide. Freeman, New York Smith PJ (2003) Learning strategies used by apprentices in flexible delivery. J of Voc Educ and Train 55(3):369¬–383 Sodha S, Guglielmi S (2009) A stitch in time: tackling educational disengagement. Demos, London Swift J, Fisher R (2012) Choosing vocational education: some views from young people in West Yorkshire. Res in Post-Comp Educ 17(2): 207–221 Thompson R (2010) Teaching on the margins: tutors, discourse and pedagogy in work-based learning for young people. J of Voc Educ and Train 62(2):123¬–137 Thomson P, Russell L (2009) Data, data everywhere – but not all the numbers that count? mapping alternative provisions for students excluded from school. Int J of Inclusive Educ 13(4):423–438 Virtanen A, Tynj{\"a}l{\"a} P, Etel{\"a}pelto A (2014) Factors promoting vocational students{\textquoteright} learning at work: study on student experiences. J of Educ and Work 27(1): 43–70 Wolf A (2011) Review of vocational education – the Wolf report. DfE, London Zemblyas M (2006) Work-based learning, power and subjectivity: creating space for a Foucauldian research ethic. J of Educ and Work 19(3):291–303",
year = "2014",
month = nov,
day = "7",
doi = "10.1186/s40461-014-0010-4",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
pages = "1--18",
journal = "Empirical Research in Vocational Education and Training",
issn = "1877-6345",
publisher = "Springer Open",
number = "10",
}
