Controlling for Prior Attainment Reduces the Positive Influence that Single-gender Classroom Initiatives Exert on High School Students’ Scholastic Achievements

Charlotte Pennington, Linda Kaye, Adam Qureshi, Derek Heim

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)
76 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Research points to the positive impact that gender-segregated schooling and classroom initiatives exert on academic attainment. However, an evaluation of these studies which reveal positive effects highlights that students are typically selectively assigned to single-gender or mixed-gender instructional settings, presenting a methodological confound. The current study controls for students’ prior attainment to appraise the efficacy of a single-gender classroom initiative implemented in a co-educational high school in the United Kingdom. Secondary data analysis (using archived data) was performed on 266 middle-ability, 11–12 year-old students’ standardized test scores in Languages (English, foreign Language), STEM-related (Mathematics, Science, Information and Communication Technology), and Non-STEM subjects (art, music, drama). Ninety-eight students (54, 55% female) were taught in single-gender and 168 (69, 41% female) in mixed-gender classrooms. Students undertook identical tests irrespective of classroom type, which were graded in accordance with U.K national curriculum guidelines. Controlling for students’ prior attainment, findings indicate that students do not appear to benefit from being taught in single-gender relative to mixed-gender classrooms in Language and STEM-related subjects. Young women benefitted from being taught in mixed-gender relative to singlegender classes for Non-STEM subjects. However, when prior ability is not controlled for, the intervention appears to be effective for all school subjects, highlighting the confounding influence of selective admissions. These findings suggest that gender-segregated classroom initiatives may not bolster students’ grades. It is argued that studies that do not control for selection effects may tell us little about the effectiveness of such interventions on scholastic achievement.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)385-393
Number of pages9
JournalSex Roles
Volume78
Issue number5-6
Early online date4 Jul 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2018

Keywords

  • Single-gender classrooms Co-education Achievement Gender-achievement gap Education policy

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Controlling for Prior Attainment Reduces the Positive Influence that Single-gender Classroom Initiatives Exert on High School Students’ Scholastic Achievements'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

  • Profiles

    No photo of Derek Heim

    Derek Heim

    Person: Academic

    No photo of LINDA KAYE

    Dr LINDA KAYE

    Person: Academic

    No photo of ADAM QURESHI

    ADAM QURESHI

    Person: Academic

    Cite this