Assessing fidelity to complex interventions: the icons experience

B Chesworth, M LEathley, L Thomas, D Forshaw, C Sutton, B French, C Burton, D Britt, Brenda Roe, F Cheater, C Watkins

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaperpeer-review

    49 Downloads (Pure)


    Background: Assessing fidelity to complex healthcare interventions in clinical trials is a challenging area. ‘ICONS' is a cluster randomised controlled feasibility trial of a systematic voiding programme (SVP), incorporating bladder training and prompted voiding, to promote post-stroke continence. Here we describe feasibility of one aspect of fidelity assessment: the day-to-day implementation of the SVP through analysis of clinical logs. Methods: Nurses completed clinical logs daily, which included documenting: the toileting interval, proposed toileting times and times toileted. Clinical logs were sampled across trial sites. The original intention was to assess fidelity by exploring the degree of concordance between proposed times and times toileted. Initial analysis revealed the unfeasibility of this method due to documentation errors in toileting intervals and proposed times. Consequently, the planned method was changed to identification of key ‘quality indicators' (QIs) for documentation of practice. Results: The need to revise the method of measurement demonstrates the difficulty in assessing fidelity. Assessment of clinical logs revealed low levels of adherence to key quality indicators. However, it is unclear whether this indicates poor fidelity or an imprecise method of fidelity assessment. Conclusion: This study highlights challenges of assessing fidelity to complex interventions. Lessons learned will inform the measurement of fidelity in a future trial. Researchers should be aware that the practical implementation of complex healthcare interventions may not be exactly as intended. For ICONS, clinical logs constituted a proxy measure of day-to-day fidelity to the intervention: identification of alternative methods could be considered.
    Original languageEnglish
    Publication statusPublished - 29 Nov 2013
    Event2nd Clinical Trials Methodology Conference: Methodology Matters - Edinburgh, United Kingdom
    Duration: 18 Nov 201319 Nov 2013


    Conference2nd Clinical Trials Methodology Conference: Methodology Matters
    Country/TerritoryUnited Kingdom


    Dive into the research topics of 'Assessing fidelity to complex interventions: the icons experience'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

    Cite this